GIRL WITH A MARBLE RYE
There’s an article in the February issue of Details that should make any aspiring writer more confident in his ability to say, with confidence, that classic aspiring-writer aphorism: ‘I can write better stuff than some of the crap that gets published.’ Sure you can. And if you’ve already mastered the rigorous English lessons of the second grade, you probably have. The stirring essay in which you detail your wacky summer vacation could be published in Details, if the editors are consistent.
Bruce Wagner is the fortunate scribe who penned the tripe, a long essay whose ostensible subject is John Stewart, our indomitable news satirist. He’s fortunate, Wagner is, because he somehow convinced the magazine to pay him for garbage. Garbage. Because that’s what it is. After the opening salvo — “I love John Stewart. I want to be John Stewart. I want to fuck John Stewart.” — Wagner decends into a bizarre, nonsensical page and a half of brainless, witless verbiage, into which he interpolates three, maybe four insights (I can only guess that he hopes these insights will protect him later on against the inevitible criticism, most of which will sound like this: “What the fuck?”)
Wagner’s little plan won’t work. It won’t work because the insights he hides in what is otherwise a masturbatory homage to his desire to either A. Fuck everything or B. put off readers with reckless disregard for his own reputation, in the hopes that such a bold maneuver can be turned around with “Oh, well I was being postmodern.” or “But you see, I made three, maybe four insights! Is it my fault you were distracted by my liberal use of the words ‘fuck, fucked and fucking’?” (and then, on cue, the last refuge of a desperate writer): “It’s not my fault. You just don’t get it.” — OK, I realize I’ve gotten very far away from where this sentence was originally going, but bear with me while I return to the thought (reread, if necessary, but please don’t flog my awful grammar) — the insights, I was saying, are jejune, at best.
Wagner has a few legitimate ideas when he starts writing. He lets the deadline creep up. He scrambles to put something together. He makes a bunch of literary and cultural allusions. He swears. He begs us to be offended. He begs us to care. He likes John Stewart (and hey, don’t we all?) but he expresses this with all of the focus of a broken lens. And John Stewart (who is quite good at satire but who, let’s face it, isn’t going to become the Great Truth Speaker of the Future, as some have posited) has already been liked. Publicly. By hundreds of writers and thousands of viewers.
So why do we care that Bruce Wagner likes him, too? Bruce must have asked himself the same question. And the only answer he could come up with is: “I want to be John Stewart’s wife’s womb.” That is, Wagner is insane with admiration for Stewart (I considered the possibility that he’s mocking the people who are insane with admiration for Stewart, but if that was his goal, he failed in making it come across). “You like him? Oh yeah? Well, I want to fuck him!”
So keep plugging away, fellow aspiring writers (or should we call ourselves writers who aspire to be published? I mean, we really do write.). There’s hope. There’s money being spent. And apparently, there’s a magazine out there called Details that will pay for just about anything.
ADDENDUM: I almost forgot to mention another of Wagner's loopholes (one that really shines a light on his own feeling about the essay — that he can't understand it any more than we can). The entire essay comprises two paragraphs. The first, the body of the beast, is rendered as one long, tedious thought. The one about fucking everything and cultural reference this and nonsense that. Wagner wants to wrap it up. It's been a long paragraph, after all. How to tie the bow? How to bring all these thoughts of wanting to fuck and wanting to be fucked to a profound conclusion?
"I wanna be me."
I wanna be me. What a fucking existential masterpiece! It's all about desire. About the human condition. About how cultural idolatry and iconography and caricature color our bleak reality. That is important stuff. Wagner's done it, by gum! (Surely, he heard these voices in his head as he typed that ultimate, one-sentence paragraph.) He's done it!
But then no, he really hasn't.